Baked fresh · Filled to the edge
Every bite has a secret center.
Indulge in our deliciously baked stuffed cookies! Made with the finest ingredients, our cookies are the perfect treat for any occasion. Try them today and satisfy your sweet cravings!
Single cookies
Every single comes in its own tin
Each single cookie is baked and packed in its own gold tin with a clear lid, so it travels safely and makes a great little gift.
- Oven-ready. Remove the lid and warm it right in the tin at 350°F for 5 minutes.
- Microwave? Remove the lid and move the cookie to a microwave-safe plate first — the tin is metal.
- Sealed fresh. Every tin carries our Stuff’d sticker.
Why stuffed?
Two cookies' worth of happy in one.
- Real fillings. Spoonfuls of spread folded into every ball of dough — never a thin swipe.
- Simple dough. Flour, sugar, butter, vanilla, salt, baking powder and milk. That's it.
- Baked to order. Small batches so your box is at its best for a full week.
The 6" box
Fill a 6" box
Every 6" box comes in our gold gift tin and holds 5 cookies. Try the Assorted box with one of each favorite, or fill a tin with a single flavor.
Ingredients & care
Straight from our label
Ingredients
Flour, sugar, butter, vanilla, salt, baking powder, milk — plus the filling of your choice.
May contain nuts: depending on flavor, and all cookies are made in the same kitchen.
Best by: 1 week after purchase.
Reheating instructions
Microwave: remove the lid and transfer into a microwave-safe container; heat for 10 seconds.
Oven: remove the lid and place into a preheated oven at 350°F for 5 minutes. No need to transfer.
Place an order
Ready when you are
Add cookies to your cart, then tell us where and when. We'll confirm by email. Questions about an order? Email order@mystuffdcookies.com.
Questions
Frequently asked
How long do the cookies stay fresh?
Enjoy them within 1 week of purchase. Keep them in their box or an airtight container at room temperature.
What's the best way to warm them up?
Remove the lid first. Microwave: transfer into a microwave-safe container and heat for 10 seconds. Oven: place into a preheated oven at 350°F for 5 minutes — no need to transfer.
Do your cookies contain nuts?
Hazelnut and Pistachio have nut fillings. All of our cookies are made in the same kitchen, so any cookie may contain traces of nuts. Please let us know about allergies in your order notes.
What's in the cookie dough?
Flour, sugar, butter, vanilla, salt, baking powder and milk — plus the filling of your choice. Double Chocolate uses a chocolate dough with a chocolate filling, and Red Velvet uses a red velvet dough with a white vanilla filling.
What comes in a 6" box?
Each 6" box is a round gold gift tin that holds 5 cookies. Single cookies come in their own small gold tin with a clear lid. Pick a single flavor for $20, or the Assorted box for $25 with one each of Hazelnut, Double Chocolate, Pistachio, Red Velvet and Biscoff.
Can I get a box of Pistachio?
Pistachio is sold as singles only, but every Assorted box includes one.
How far ahead should I order?
Orders need at least one day’s notice so we can bake them fresh. For large or party orders, please contact us a few days ahead.
Do you deliver?
Yes — choose local delivery at checkout for an extra $5, or pick up for free. We’ll confirm the details by email.
Do you take custom or event orders?
We’d love to! Use the contact form below to tell us the date, quantity and flavors you have in mind.
Contact us
Say hello
Questions, custom orders, events or feedback — send us a note and we’ll get back to you by email.
Custom & party orders
Planning a birthday, office treat or event? Tell us the date, how many cookies and your favorite flavors.